$5,000,000 Jury Award in Wrongful Death/Medical Malpractice Case By Younker Hyde Macfarlane on November 03, 2021

Judge with gavel

Personal injury attorneys Ashton Hyde and John Macfarlane secured a $5,000,000 jury award, on September 24, 2021, for the children of a 67-year-old woman who died following the improper withdrawal of life sustaining care by her doctors.

The jury found that Lillian “Lil” Birt’s death on April 25, 2016, was the result of Dr. Wei Peng and Dr. Christina G. Richards’ negligence. Fourteen days prior, Ms. Birt had suffered a surgical complication. However, she was improving and likely to survive and make a good recovery. The jury found that Dr. Peng and Dr. Richards failed to adequately explain Ms. Birt’s good prognosis to the family. Instead, Dr. Peng and Dr. Richards certified Ms. Birt as terminal and agreed to withdraw life sustaining care, resulting in Ms. Birt’s death.

The Surgery 

Ms. Birt underwent laparoscopic hiatal hernia repair on April 11, 2016. The procedure was performed by Dr. Daniel Cottam at Salt Lake Regional Medical Center. During the procedure, Dr. Cottam caused an enterotomy into Ms. Birt’s bowels. Dr. Cottam attempted to repair the injury.

Reports of Worsening Conditions 

The day after the surgery, Ms. Birt presented to Dr. Richards with vital signs consistent with bowel perforation / enterotomy and developing sepsis. In the three days following the operation, Ms. Birt experienced increased abdominal pain and her mental state changed significantly as she became more confused. 

On April 14, 2016, Ms. Birt had a clinical visit with Dr. Cottam in which he sent her to the emergency room. The next day, Dr. Cottam assisted Dr. Richards in performing exploratory surgery, during which a 3mm perforation, located in the bowel area that was operated on days earlier, was repaired. 

Withdrawal of Care 

After the perforation repair, there was difficulty weaning Ms. Birt from the ventilator, and the family was under the impression that Ms. Birt’s prognosis was poor. However, it was actually improving. Ms. Birt’s healthcare providers believed she would survive and make a full or near-full recovery. The improved prognosis was not conveyed to the family. As a result, the family inquired about withdrawal of care. Instead of explaining Ms. Birt’s improved prognosis and advocating for continued care, Dr. Peng and Dr. Richards certified Ms. Birt as terminal and withdrew life-sustaining care. She died on April 25th, 2016. 

The Trial 

During the nine-day trial, Younker Hyde Macfarlane alleged that Ms. Birt should never have been certified as terminal and care should not have been withdrawn. The jury agreed and found that Dr. Richards and Dr. Peng breached the standard of care by failing to adequately inform the family regarding Ms. Birt’s prognosis and failing to properly advocate for continued care. The jury also found that, but for the negligent actions of Dr. Richards and Dr. Peng, Ms. Birt would not have died and would have likely experienced a full or near-full recovery.

The jury awarded general damages of $2 million to each of Ms. Birt’s surviving children. The jury also awarded $1 million to Ms. Birt’s estate for her pain and suffering prior to her death. 

Contact Our Practice 

If your loved one has suffered injury or death due to medical malpractice, contact our Salt Lake City practice today to request a free case review. You can also reach us by phone at (801) 335-6467. 

Related to This

Younker Hyde Macfarlane, PLLC

Younker Hyde Macfarlane, PLLC

At Younker Hyde Macfarlane, PLLC, our attorneys have decades of combined experience in complex cases. We represent clients in all types of personal injury cases, with a special focus on medical malpractice claims. Our firm is associated with the following professional organizations:

  • Utah Bar Association
  • American Bar Association
  • Salt Lake County Bar Association
  • American Trial Lawyers Association

To schedule an appointment, please contact us online or call (801) 335-6467.

Free Consultation Today

"They were extremely knowledgeable, extremely helpful experts. The team helped me with all aspects of my case, including medical and financial, and understood that it affected more than me but also my family."

Rate, Review & Explore

Social Accounts Sprite
Google map image of our location in 257 E 200 S Ste 1080 Salt Lake City, UT

Salt Lake City Office

257 E 200 S
Ste 1080
Salt Lake City, UT 84111

Open Today 8:00am - 5:00pm

Tell us a bit about yourself...

801-335-6467 Send a message